What Makes A Great/Good Architecture Competition? Part 1: The Jury Panel

What Makes A Great/Good Architecture Competition? Part 1: The Jury Panel

There are a lot of factors that go into making a great architecture competition, from an exciting topic, a challenging brief, and an opportunity to showcase your passions and talents. One factor that gets overlooked all-too often is the role of the jury panel in making an architecture competition engaging and fulfilling for its participants.

1. The size of the jury panel

You’ve heard the phrase, too many cooks spoil the broth? Well, too many jury members can ruin the chance of awarding some amazing project submissions with first prize. With over-sized jury panels the debate and indecision will not only make the judging process incredibly long but will make it highly ineffective.

What Makes A Great/Good Architecture Competition? Part 1: The Jury Panel

While it is impossible to please everyone all the time, architecture competition winners typically stand out and a jury panel will tend to shortlist many of the same project submissions. With 10, 12, 14, etc jury members this makes for a very long shortlist that is difficult to whittle down in order to choose winners.

Note: Bee Breeders limits its jury panel to no more than five professionals

2. The background/experience of the jury panel

It’s not just the size of the jury, but also who makes it up. Each competition is different and will often require a varied set of backgrounds and opinions to select the winning entry. However, many large-scale architecture competitions have been known to include numerous members of the media and company marketing departments, leaving little room for architecture professionals and academics to make their voices heard.

A recent architecture competition to create a Holocaust memorial in London had a massive 14-member jury panel, many of whom were media figures, politicians, celebrities and intermediaries. With many of the jurors unable to fully understand the architectural concepts in the submitted projects, its typical to favour lower-risk, more consensual options.

3. A celebrity jury member isn’t always a good thing

What Makes A Great/Good Architecture Competition? Part 1: The Jury Panel

Having a celebrity guest judge has done wonders for TV talent shows, but architecture competitions that have a celebrity judge don’t necessarily produce better winning projects. Having a big name attached to a competition will get it some extra media attention and possibly more entries, but there is no guarantee that the ‘big name’ will maka a great jury panel member.

Very often they will receive a fee for attaching their name to the project, rather than taking part because of their passion for either the project or for architecture and design in general.

4. Providing feedback to the winners

With some open architecture competitions receiving hundreds of project submissions, it’s not always going to be possible to give feedback to every single entry. However, a jury panel will have plenty of views and opinions on their selected winning entries that can and should be shared along with the finalist selections.

If a jury panel simply selects their winners and announces them in a press release without any further information, the participants lose out on valuable information that could help them improve their work and encourage them to take part in more competitions in the future.

Open architecture competition organisers like Bee Breeders, on the other hand, give feedback on all of the selected winning entries, describing their decision process in detail in relation to the brief and the quality of the project submissions.

What to look for in an architecture competition jury

What Makes A Great/Good Architecture Competition? Part 1: The Jury Panel

When deciding to take part in architecture competitions, be sure to look to past entries and winning project announcements. The organizers should include comments from the jury panel explaining why they were passionate about the projects they selected as winners. Don’t get distracted by big names or massive jury panels; an involved and enthusiastic jury is more important in making your architecture competition experience a great one.

Open architecture competitions

  • Closest Deadline first
  • Project competitions first
    Selected winning projects have the potential to be constructed
  • Ideas competitions first
    Experimental competitions with the focus on pushing the boundaries of creativity
ideas COMPETITION
Toronto Affordable Housing Challenge

Design affordable housing solutions for Toronto

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + PUBLICATION IN THE BOOK
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 16
Jan 28
Apr 22
Register now
ideas COMPETITION
SKYHIVE 2021 Skyscraper Challenge

Fourth annual competition to redefine the modern-day skyscraper

Prize: MONETARY AWARD
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 17
Jan 29
Apr 23
Register now
project COMPETITION
Sleeping Pods on a Cliff

Design a series of sleeping pods for a Portugal yoga retreat

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 18
Feb 01
Apr 27
Register now
project COMPETITION
Tiny Kiwi Meditation Cabin

Design a meditation space in New Zealand

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 21
Feb 02
Apr 28
Register now
project COMPETITION
Spirala Community Home

Create a community home for the Spirala Ecological Village

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 22
Feb 03
Apr 29
Register now
ideas COMPETITION
The Last Nuclear Bomb Memorial

Design a memorial that speaks towards the cause of ending all nuclear weapons

Prize: MONETARY AWARD
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 15
Jan 27
Apr 21
Register now
project COMPETITION
Omuli Museum of the Horse

Reimagine a historical primary school into a museum for horses

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Dec 14
Jan 26
Apr 23
Register now

ARCHITECTURE COMPETITIONS

Newsletter