International Architecture Competition

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Results

Foreword

Competition organisers

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

The winners of Bee Breeders architecture competition organisers’ latest architecture competition have been selected from over 120 submissions from architecture enthusiasts from around the world. The competition challenged participants to design a temporary pavilion for the education of social, political and religious tolerance, to be erected in Russia’s Red Square, Moscow.

The quality of the submissions was extremely high and the winners were chosen for the strength of their concept, originality, quality of their presentation and, most importantly, political and social influence of their design. The judges placed a particular focus on each project's concept and its respective ability to manifest the idea of tolerance and leave a strong impact on this politically-charged site. Bee Breeders would like to thank all the entrants who took part and are extremely proud of the winning designs.

The three winning concepts came from design teams based in Italy, Norway and France respectively, showing how the theme of tolerance is important and relevant in countries spanning the globe and that world-class design is universal.

Competition results in media publications

1ST PRIZE WINNER

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Italy

Project authors

Kiana Jalali
Alessandro Vitale
Matteo Pagani
Marco Merigo

jury commentary

This project, although seemingly quite simple, carries great potential to spread the message of tolerance. The choice to move the structure away from the center of the square is a strong one, and its location against the Kremlin Wall speaks powerfully. In the space created by this project, visitors are forced to confront the wall's darker past as they are educated about a tolerant future, thus creating a powerful dichotomy. Throughout the project, there are also a series of framed views from the structure, and even the subtle incline of the facade speaks metaphorically of inviting the public inside. The full transparency within the space, even down to the chosen stair details of transparent treads and risers, continues this idea of welcoming and acceptance. The choice of a white facade in direct contrast to the red brick wall behind is also one that speaks of peace, forgiveness, and hope.

As a temporary pavilion, the removal of this intervention could also be politically charged, as the lack of weathering behind this facade would leave a physical imprint on the wall. This would continue to remind visitors of the power of tolerance, thus embodying the enduring social and political footprint that this competition seeks.

Finally, the provocative ideas put forth in the concept and design of this project are followed elegantly with a presentation that clearly illustrates the desired juxtaposition between the tyranny of the wall and the pure hope for a tolerant future. This is most clearly illustrated with the elevation rendering, which illustrates a glowing white beacon triumphing over a totalitarian past.


2ND PRIZE WINNER

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Norway

Project authors

Mesi Koponen
Ida Sandvik

jury commentary

This project features a series of clever solutions to engaging and sharing the subject of tolerance. The choice to position the pavilion so that it crosses the entire width of the square is successful in its utilitarian nature of intercepting all visitors crossing the square. In this same position it is also forming a metaphorical blockade against the military routes outlined in the paving of the square. The slightly voyeuristic nature of the concept is also provocative in the manner that everyone in the square becomes a participant in educating the public about tolerance. Through many plied layers of colored glass, one's view of the passersby in the square is reduced to a series of silhouettes, which poetically alludes to the fact that without the pretense of our own prejudices (i.e. a clear view of another human being that we can judge), we are all equal.

Aside from the strong and clear ideas incorporated into this project, the presentation itself is equally powerful in its clarity and simplicity. Of particular note is the eloquence of the narrative on the first board, which the judges found to be at the heart of the idea of the competition.

Additional noteworthy details reveal themselves as one realizes, for example, that the image on the first board is illustrating a red square, and is yet in philosophical contrast to the Red Square competition site itself. The project is successful in clearly illustrating an idea that directly confronts intolerance - that everything is not always as it seems - and that it is only through understanding and acceptance that we can embrace tolerance.

3RD PRIZE WINNER

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

France

Project authors

Nicolas Souchko

jury commentary

This project exhibits a straightforward concept that is presented very clearly and represented beautifully. The idea of folding or twisting together various minority groups is quite unique and manifests itself well architecturally. Additionally, the programmatic planning of the pavilion has a refreshing clarity - showing a somewhat religious ascension towards a tolerant enlightenment. Each of the petals contains a different gallery, and as they each fold into each other they reveal a sequence of experiences that culminates in a common central space for gathering and exchanging ideas. The unspoken metaphor of a flower is also present, which sets a tone of growth and beauty. The contrast between the materiality of this pavilion and the rest of the square, namely the Kremlin Wall, brings a subtle poetry to the scheme. The key image of the presentation shows a series of translucent petals lifting into the air in contrast to the weight of its monolithic red neighbor, which further reinforces the concept of a welcoming and tolerant space that stands directly in front of, and in direct contrast to, the Kremlin Wall. The presentation itself is also particularly noteworthy, and included some of the highest quality images amongst the entries. These images are successful in conveying how a series of simple architectural moves can successfully set the scene for a didactic and tolerant environment.



Honorable mentions

VIEWclose HONOURABLE MENTIONS

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Belarus

Project authors

Andrei Sashko
Volha Bortnik

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

United States

Project authors

Cameron Irwin

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Denmark

Project authors

Thomas O'Brien
Emile de Wit

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Poland

Project authors

Justyna Mydlak
Natalia Podejko

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Spain

Project authors

Javier Ignacio Martinez Garcia

Project Name

Red Square Tolerance Pavilion

Country

Korea

Project authors

Hyung Seok Yoon

Open architecture competitions

  • Closest Deadline first
  • Project competitions first
    Selected winning projects have the potential to be constructed
  • Ideas competitions first
    Experimental competitions with the focus on pushing the boundaries of creativity
project COMPETITION
Iceland Cave Tower

Design observation tower overlooking the mysteriously beautiful Grjótagjá caves in northern Iceland

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 30
Sep 22
Nov 17
Register now
project COMPETITION
Cambodia Remote Hideout Huts

Design a series of remote hideout huts to be located in Cambodia

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jul 01
Sep 23
Nov 18
Register now
ideas COMPETITION
Melbourne Affordable Housing Challenge

Design affordable housing solutions for Australia’s fastest-growing city

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + PUBLICATION IN THE BOOK
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 16
Sep 08
Nov 03
Register now
ideas COMPETITION
MICROHOME 2020 - Small living, huge impact!

Design a new concept of small-scale architecture with the second annual Microhomes competition

Prize: MONETARY AWARD
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 07
Sep 09
Nov 04
Register now
ideas COMPETITION
Pavilion Of Humanity: First Contact

How would you represent the best that humanity has to offer through architecture?

Prize: MONETARY AWARD
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 23
Sep 15
Nov 10
Register now
essay COMPETITION
What is Sustainable Architecture?

Share your opinion on sustainable architecture in the open essay competition

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + PUBLICATION IN THE BOOK
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 24
Sep 16
Nov 11
Register now
project COMPETITION
Yoga House on a Cliff

Design eco-friendly yoga house in a secluded Portuguese retreat

Prize: MONETARY AWARD + CONSTRUCTION
Eligibility: OPEN TO ALL

registration deadlines

Remind me
Jun 25
Sep 17
Nov 12
Register now
To access competion downloads please enter your email address:
OK
To access competion downloads please enter your email address:
OK
This website uses cookies for enhancing the user experience and tracking usage statistics.
More information is available in our Privacy Policy.